In a recent story on New Economic Perspectives, a website offering policy advice and economic analysis, William K Black comments on David Roodman’s article in the Washington Post, “Microcredit doesn’t end poverty, despite all the hype,” which was published on March 11, 2012. Mr Black expands Roodman’s points by analyzing the Bosnian microfinance market through the lens of the research paper published in January 2012, “Bosnia’s Microfinance Meltdown.” The paper by Milford Bateman, Dean Sinkovic and Marinko Skare, blames the turmoil among microfinance institutions in Bosnia on senior management of microfinance institutions (MFIs). Despite microfinance being praised for “promoting bottom-up economic and social development,” the research paper indicates that microcredit in Bosnia is “radically different from the original model that was praised and received a Nobel peace prize” [2]. The research paper asserts that microcredit contributed to the current economic crunch in Bosnia, drawing a parallel to the subprime lending downturn that started in the US in 2007.
Among the factors cited as having caused the failure of the microfinance sector in Bosnia are microfinance loans being used for consumption rather than small businesses; a 50-percent failure rate for new businesses; fierce competition among new and existing businesses; over-indebtedness and multiple borrowing among microfinance customers; insufficient due diligence such as the use of credit bureaus; fraud committed by CEO’s and exorbitant financial incentives for senior managers.
The Black Model for Control Fraud, which was developed by Mr Black to explain the rise and fall of US savings and loan institutions in the 1980’s, is used to describe how Bosnia suffers from management control fraud today. The model provides a framework to predict that senior managers would forecast MFIs’ unsustainable growth; seek psychological rewards associated with being the most profitable MFI; try to enrich themselves by converting the MFI’s assets into their own and harbor resistance towards government regulators.
By Amira Berrada, Research Associate
Sources and Resources
[1] http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2012/03/microcredit-accounting-contro…
[2] “Bosnia’s Microfinance Meltdown”;
http://www.microfinancegateway.org/gm/document-1.9.56293/Bosnia_Meltdown…
[3] http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/microcredit-doesnt-end-poverty-de…
MicroCapital.org article, January 8, 2010, “MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Critics Claim that Bosnian Microfinance Institutions Simply Issuing ‘Commercial Loans Masquerading as Microfinance’” https://www.microcapital.org/microcapital-brief-critics-claim-that-bosnia…
MicroCapital.org article, October 18, 2011, “MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Center for Financial and Credit Counseling of Bosnia Offers Debt Mediation, Financial Education to Microfinance Clients” https://www.microcapital.org/microcapital-brief-center-for-financial-and-…
MicroCapital.org article, February 25, 2012, “MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: responsAbility Lends $4.5m to Microfinance Institutions in Romania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kyrgyz Republic” https://www.microcapital.org/microcapital-brief-responsability-lends-4-5m…
Browse the MicroCapital Universe and add your entry to the wiki at: https://www.microcapital.org/microfinanceuniverse/
Similar Posts:
- MICROFINANCE PAPER WRAP-UP: “Land Titling and Microcredit in Cambodia: Examining the Reality of Hernando de Soto’s ‘Three Steps to Heaven,’” by Milford Bateman
- MICROFINANCE PAPER WRAP-UP: “Mobile Money, Interoperability and Financial Inclusion;” by Markus K Brunnermeier et al; published by National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER)
- MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Papara of Turkiye Acquires Rebellion Pay Mobile Money Service from Beka Finance of Spain in Cash, Equity Deal
- MICROFINANCE PAPER WRAP-UP: “Gendered Investment Differences Among Smallholder Farmers: Evidence from a Microcredit Programme in Western Kenya,” by Keiji Jindo et al
- MICROFINANCE PAPER WRAP-UP: “The Relationship Between Financial and Social Performances in Microfinance: Insights from the Provision of Agricultural Loans in Cambodia,” by Tristan Caballero-Montes