Why So Few Profitable MFIs? | MicroCapital
  • MicroCapital Monitor

    MicroCapital Monitor<br>Subscribe to our monthly market report
    We can email you everything you need to know about microfinance news, research, events and key players.

  • External Links

    Absolute Portfolio Management - Vision Microfinance Fund

    Microenterprise Learning, Information & Knowledge Sharing

    Treetops Capital Microfinance SMEs Housing Agribusiness

    Microfinance Association Ratings

    Carsey Institute Trainings Ghana; Togo; New Hampshire, USA; Tanzania







    • Banking

      Banking your way just got easier.

    • Checking

      The convenience of checking – the interest rate of savings

    • Savings & CDs

      Choose the right option for the way you save.

» Currently browsing: Why So Few Profitable MFIs?


Wednesday, April 27, 2011

MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Mexican Microfinance Institution (MFI) Banco Compartamos Reports First Quarter Profits Up 14% to $39m, Plans to Expand to Guatemala

Banco Compartamos, a Mexican microfinance bank, reported net income growth of 14.8 percent to MXN 459 million (USD 39.5 million) and net operating income growth of 19.2 percent to MXN 702 million (USD 60.4 million) for the first quarter of 2011, as compared with the same period in 2010. Increased revenues came primarily from delinquency fees and voluntary life insurance premiums, resulting in growth of 21.6 percent over the first quarter of 2010. Continue Reading »



Tuesday, March 22, 2011

MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Microfinance Information Exchange (MIX) Analyzes Profitability of Microfinance Institutions (MFIs)

Data collected by Microfinance Information Exchange (MIX), the US-based nonprofit data provider, contradicts the idea that the commercialization of microfinance is increasing the vulnerability of low-income households [1] [2]. Continue Reading »



Thursday, March 10, 2011

MICROCAPITAL BRIEF: Microcredit Summit Campaign Releases State of the Microcredit Summit Campaign Report 2011, Reports 128m Poor People Received Microfinance Loans in 2009

The Microcredit Summit Campaign, a project that was launched in 1997 by US-based nonprofit advocacy group RESULTS Educational Fund (REF), recently released the State of the Microcredit Summit Campaign Report 2011, a plenary account of the recent trends, challenges and achievements in the microfinance industry, at the National Press Club in Washington, DC. The report indicated that 128 million poor people received microloans in 2009, more than was recorded in any of the organization’s previous reports. In 1997, 7.6 million were estimated to have received microloans. Continue Reading »



Monday, June 1, 2009

MICROCAPITAL STORY: State Bank of Pakistan Adds Incentive to Micro Credit Guarantee Facility

The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has issued a new circular that it will provide a 25 percent first loss guarantee for loans under its Micro Credit Guarantee Facility (MCGF) to further encourage commercial banks to provide wholesale funds to microfinance institutions (MFIs).  The Facility was introduced last December but was met with an unenthusiastic response by banks despite the SBP’s 40 percent principal guarantee on loans.  According to the press release in the Daily Times of Pakistan, only one loan has been granted so far under the MCGF.  Banks and development finance institutions (DFIs) now will have the option of choosing either the 40 percent principal guarantee (pari passu), or the 25 percent first loss guarantee.  The first loss guarantee will cover gaps in repayment of a loan’s principal, up to 25 percent of the principal value of the loan, whereas the 40 percent principal guarantee will cover 40 percent of the actual loss incurred.  In essence the first loss guarantee covers a bank’s smaller losses upfront completely, while the 40 percent principal guarantee would require the bank to share in the losses but covers a larger percentage of loss. Continue Reading »



Tuesday, May 5, 2009

NEWS WIRE: Microfinance Effectiveness Examined

Source: Times Online 
Continue Reading »



Wednesday, October 8, 2008

MICROCAPITAL STORY: Indian Technology Company, Comat, Raises $12.5m from Omiydar Network and Unitus Equity Fund of the United States

Comat, a technology company providing services to rural India, recently raised INR 60 crore (USD 12.5m) from the Omidyar Network and the Unitus Equity Fund (UEF). According to a Business Standard article, the new investment will allow “Comat to expand to new States, accelerate service delivery for training and financial services [and] strengthen management bandwidth.” Continue Reading »



Thursday, June 14, 2007

PAPER WRAP-UP: "Microfinance Misses its Mark," by Aneel Karnani

Written by Aneel Karnani, published by Standford Social Innovation Review, Summer 2007, 8 pages, available at: http://www.ssireview.org/images/articles/2007SU_feature_karnani.pdf

In an article published in Stanford Social Innovation Review, a magazine of Stanford Graduate School of Business, University of Michigan’s Dr. Aneel Karnani argues against investment in microfinance. As the essay’s title articulates, “Microfinance Misses its Mark,” the professor argues that microfinance “does not significantly alleviate poverty.”

Continue reading “PAPER WRAP-UP: "Microfinance Misses its Mark," by Aneel Karnani”



Tuesday, November 21, 2006

What ProCredit Does to Increase Profitability

This Christian Science Monitor article, while focusing on for-profit microfinance, has used bits about ProCredit to profile a for-profit organization. However, they don’t seem to have done a very comprehensive job of it.
Continue reading “What ProCredit Does to Increase Profitability”



Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Uganda to Cap Interest Rates Charged By Microfinance Institutions

The Ugandan government capped the interest rate that microfinance institutions may charge. According to New Vision Kampala, the new rule sets rates at or below inflation, which stood at 8.1% in 2005. Microfinance institutions in Uganda currently lend at rates of 18 to 100 percent.

Continue reading “Uganda to Cap Interest Rates Charged By Microfinance Institutions”



Tuesday, August 15, 2006

Can a State-owned Microfinance Institution Succeed? A Look at Colombia’s New Banco de las Oportunidades

In his inaugural speech this month, Colombia’s President Alvaro Uribe outlined plans to create a new microcredit bank. Capitalized with 120 billion Colombian pesos (equivalent to $50 million) from the state-owned bank, Bancafe, the new Banco de las Oportunidades will focus on low-income groups and microlending. President Uribe promised that this will create credit opportunities for more than six million low-income Colombians.

Continue reading “Can a State-owned Microfinance Institution Succeed? A Look at Colombia’s New Banco de las Oportunidades”



Wednesday, July 26, 2006

The Korea Times of South Korea Says Microcredit Is a Failure “due to lack of private donations and government support”

Apparently, microfinance in South Korea has failed. The Korea Times, a South Korean daily newspaper, attributes this failure to “lack of private donations and government support.” The South Korean government established the Social Solidarity Bank (SSB), the nation’s first non-governmental microfinance institution, in 2002. Since its inception, SSB attracted corporate donations of 3 billion won (USD $3.15 million), in large part from conglomerate Samsung Group and Kookmin Bank. However, The Korea Times believes this was “a miniscule amount of money and not enough to allow the bank to operate as a financial institution.”

Continue reading “The Korea Times of South Korea Says Microcredit Is a Failure “due to lack of private donations and government support””



Friday, February 10, 2006

The Numbers Are In: Microbanks Continue To Demonstrate The Potential Of Microfinance Investment

MIX Market has released a report highlighting 2004 benchmarks on the performance of retail microfinance providers. The study evaluates over 300 institutions from around the world. Some key highlights from this robust data set include:

- MFI growth is significant: Globally, growth in borrowers increased by 30% in 2004. In South Asia and the Middle East åö growth in borrowers was even stronger, topping off at 50%.

- Profitable institutions reach more people. Overall profitable MFIs add 25% more borrowers than their unprofitable counterparts. Profitable MFIs cover much more ground åö the 70% of MFIs earning 2004 profits reach well over 90% of total borrowers.”

- Scale and employee productivity help MFIs cut transaction costs and increase profitability. For example, as MFIs grow from 10,000 to 30,000 clients, cost per borrower plummets from 130 to 65 USD per borrower.

“These benchmarks draw on the largest benchmarking data set ever compiled by the MIX, with 302 institutions covering the diversity of institutional types within the sector and their various stages of development.”

For the full report, head to www.mixmarket.org and scroll to the bottom of the page to access data files.

Source

“MIX Market 2004 Benchmarks,” www.mixmarket.org, February 3, 2006



Tuesday, January 24, 2006

Microfinance Picking Up Steam in Peru: Mibanco Backed by Top Industry Investors

Peruvian MFI, Mibanco, is off to the races. Guidance for 2006 is for 23% growth in profits and a 45% increase in lending. This comes after a banner year in 2005 that saw 74% growth in profits.

Continue reading “Microfinance Picking Up Steam in Peru: Mibanco Backed by Top Industry Investors”



Wednesday, January 4, 2006

BusinessWeek Plugs Remittances and Microfinance as the Converging Paths Toward Investment in Two Billion Micro-Mortgages

In an article on remittances and microfinance, Business Week has correctly pegged remittances as a potentially huge opportunity for “recipients to save money and build credit histories, so they can get mortgages and small-business loans.” Indeed, the predictable income of remittances allows poor borrowers to access more sophisticated products like “micro-mortgages”, previously limited to people with documented income and greater assets.
Continue reading “BusinessWeek Plugs Remittances and Microfinance as the Converging Paths Toward Investment in Two Billion Micro-Mortgages”



Wednesday, October 26, 2005

PBS Produces Microcredit Documentary Premiering This Week

Filmmakers Sterling Van Wagensen and Matt Whitaker have created the documentary “Small Fortunes: Microcredit and the Future of Poverty.” The table below provides local broadcast times.

City

Station

Dates

Times

Atlanta

WPBA 30

Tues, 11/1
Sun, 11/6

Austin

KLRU – HD (Hi-Def)
KLRU 2
KLRU – HD (Hi-Def)

Thurs, 10/27
Fri, 10/28
Sat, 10/29

/ () /

Boston

WGBH 44

Fri, 10/28

Chicago

WTTW – DT (Digital)

Mon, 10/31
Tues, 11/1
Fri, 11/4
Sat, 11/5

/ / / / /

Dallas

KERA

Sun, 10/30

Denver

KRMA

Sun, 10/30

() MST

Houston

Houston PBS Hi-Def

Thurs, 10/27
Sat, 10/29

()/

Los Angeles

KCET (Hi Def)

Thurs, 10/27
Sat, 10/29

/ / / /

Minneapolis

TPT 17

Mon, 10/31

New York

13 World (WNET cable)

Mon, 10/31

/ / /

Philadelphia

WHYY

Sun, 11/6

Portland

OPB

Thurs, 10/27

Provo

KBYU

Thurs 10/27

Salt

Lake

KUED-7

Sun, 11/6

San Francisco

KVIE (

Sacramento)

Thurs, 10/27
Fri, 10/28
Sat, 10/29

/ /

Seattle

KCTS-DT (Hi-Def)

Thurs, 10/27

/

St. Louis

KETC 9

Sun, 11/6

() CST

Washington DC

WETA 26

Thurs, 10/27



Monday, October 24, 2005

Google Foundation Makes $5 Million Microfinance Investment into Acumen Fund

The Google Foundation’s $5 million gift to the Acumen Fund goes to show that "making a philanthropic investment" in international small/sustainable business development is fashionable. Google would never do anything out of fashion. The Google Foundation is the “philanthropic arm of google.”

The Rockefeller Foundation, Cisco Systems Foundation, and individual philanthropists established the Acumen Fund in 2001. The Acumen Fund is an international non-profit venture fund that provides loans, equity investments, grants and “intellectual capital” to enterprises that support progress in health, housing, and water. At the end of 2004, the Acumen Fund had total disbursed loans of $2.964 million. The Fund aims to achieve approximately a negative -20% return on investment.Additional Resources
1)
“Google.org Partnership.”
2) “Acumen Fund: Our Mission.”
3) “Acumen Fund: Investment Approach.”
4) “Acumen Fund: Investment Report August 2005.”
5) “Google”



Monday, October 3, 2005

MicroCapital Paper Review: “Great Expectations: Microfinance and Poverty Reduction in Asia and Latin America”

To access this article visit: “Great Expectations: Microfinance and Poverty Reduction in Asia and Latin America”

Authors: John Weiss and Heather Montgomery

Published by: Asian Development Bank Institute, September 2004

Quantitative Information: This article compares the development and status of microfinance within two regions: Asia and Latin America. The authors suggest Asia is more effective at reaching the poor, whereas Latin America is more advanced in developing microenterprise åö using the average loan balance per borrower of US$581 in Latin America versus US$195 in Asia to back their argument. Moreover, the article cites a Mix Market, a World Bank information clearing house on microfinance, report that only 10% of Latin American MFIs specified that they were targeting “very poor clients.”

Qualitative Information: Introduced as evolving for different purposes, microfinance within Latin America åö initially having a greater focus on commercial profitability åö is contrasted against Asia and the ideals of the Grameen Bank, a famous Bangladeshi microfinance institution (MFI). The authors propose that although NGOs are still important players within Latin America, there is a significant trend toward the commercialization of microfinance and thus MFIs’ focus on profitability. The article suggests that rural, impoverished regions particularly within larger countries such as Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina are under-addressed, but neither provides examples to support these statements nor distinguishes the types of MFIs and their target markets. While the authors agree that there are indications that MFIs have an impact on borrowers within Latin America, MFIs remain unsuccessful at reaching the poorest åö although they offer little propositions for MFIs to both achieve profitability and successfully touch the pooråÐest. They do, however, suggest more studies are needed on the impact and cost effectiveness of microfinance programs.



Wednesday, September 28, 2005

A Little Breath of Fresh Air Teases the Microfinance Buy Side

Accion and Unitus, two US non-profit microfinance "networks" announced a partnership to work together in India. While good to see even a hint of industry consolidation on the non-profit "buy" or "supply" side of microfinance, it would be great to see actual mergers and acquisitions in these networks. "Networks" are loosely defined as rich country non-profits that support microfinance institution (MFI) partners or members transnationally. Almost all the 14 major network players have small budgets, as is typical of the non-profit sector. In fact, approximately 99% of all registered US non-profits have budgets less than $100 million and about 98% have budgets less than $10 million. This absence of large-scale solutions to social problems shames all of us in the face of global poverty.

As we hope to see consolidation of the 10,000 world-wide micro-lenders, we also hope to see consolidation of all the public and charitable organizations that spawned them.

Additional Resources

1) ACCION Press Release: “Microfinance Leaders ACCION and Unitus Establish Strategic Alliance for India.”
2) MicroCapital Blog: “Microfinance Networks (transnational second-tier): Defined and Listed.”
3) “Registered Non-Profit Organizations by Level of Total Income.”